Will Gates Funding “Front Teacher Organizations (E4E)” Influence or Anger Union Members?

As you walk past the gauntlet of pamphleteers at union meetings the various caucuses hand out their latest scree, individual teachers, obscure political parties, you can collect a pile of “appeals” before you reach the table with the agenda and “official” union handouts.

Teacher unions have a long history of active internal politics.

The UFT, the “United” Federation of Teachers was a merger of the Teacher Guild and the High School Teachers Association (HSTA). “Opposition” caucuses within the UFT have risen and fallen around issues – from the War in Vietnam to student discipline to contract issues.

At the Delegate Meetings the thousand delegates meet monthly to debate and set union policies. One caucus wears red shirts, caucus members frequently identify themselves as they speak at the microphone.

Diane Ravitch reports that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation have granted Educators 4 Excellence (E4E) three million dollars.

Who are these guys and gals and why do Bill and Melinda like them so much?

E4E claims a membership of a thousand union members in New York City. E4E does not run candidates in union elections nor do they hold chapter leaderships or delegate positions, if they do, they never identify themselves at union meetings.

A couple of years ago at a meeting of a not-for-profit hosting many newer teachers I sat on a panel with Evan Stone – the E4E leader at that time.

Evan spoke for the organization which opposes current tenure provisions, opposes “last in-first out” seniority layoff rules (both in State law) and supports teacher evaluation by student test scores as one component – read the core principles here

E4E has chapters in New York, Los Angeles and Minnesota and appears to be building a chapter in New Haven. While the glossy website calls E4E a membership organization, they list the area leaders, who are full time staff as well as a list of other full time staff, the website does not list a Board of Trustees, or an Executive Board, or any evidence of an elected leadership.

E4E appears to be a “fifth column,” an organization within the union, funded externally, opposing local union policies. E4E issues press releases, claims to speak for new teachers, without, at least in New York, entering union election politics.

Do they have a thousand members? A hundred members? How do they define a member?

It appears as if the Gates folk are kicking in three million to try and influence internal union politics. The mayors in New York City and Los Angeles were/are battling with the teacher unions and E4E had easy access to the mayor. In New York State the Commissioner, John King, held a high profile meeting at an E4E meeting.

With a new mayor in Los Angeles and a new mayor coming in New York, both probably much closer to the teacher union it is likely that E4E as currently formulated will have less access to school district leadership.

On the national level the Gates folk have partnered with the AFT on a number of projects and on the local level the UFT worked with Gates on the Methods of Effective Teaching (MET) project.

Rather than Gates and their child, E4E, influencing union policies they probably have the opposite effect. Unions cannot be sanguine when an outside organization pours dollars into an organization within the union to influence union members.

My advice to E4E members: if you want to influence union policy get involved, run for chapter leader, run for delegate, join a caucus, make a one-minute speech at a twice-monthly Executive Board meeting, hand out flyers at union meetings, write a blog, all perfectly acceptable methods of influencing your peers.

As a teacher do you support the current emphasis on high stakes testing? Do you think your Growth Score accurately reflects your teaching ability?

If the answers are “no,” why do you belong to an organization that advocates these policies?

If the Gates policy wonks think that by funding oppositional groups within teacher unions they will somehow move unions closer to Gates core principles they are mistaken, actually they achieve the opposite. Union members see E4E as Quislings, advocating views antithetical to core union principles, and, embedding attitudes that the Gates Foundation is anti-teacher and anti-public school.

That three million could fund a dozen Community Schools in high poverty neighborhoods, or, provide extended school days in the lowest achieving middle schools, or, heaven forbid, scholarships for teachers to attend intensive university summer programs.
Maybe that former Teacher for America policymaker in Seattle isn’t making decisions in the best interests of the Gates Foundation. Angering the folks you want to influence just doesn’t make much sense.


5 responses to “Will Gates Funding “Front Teacher Organizations (E4E)” Influence or Anger Union Members?

  1. Foil Jacqueline

    I have an additional suggestion about finding out additional information about E4E, the Leadership of the UFT, either the President who someone he assigns should speak to a person or persons from that organization and ask the questions you ask in this piece.


  2. By the way those Union members wearing red t-shirts and advocating for a strong union that will actually do battle with Gates and the other profiteers are The Movement of Rank-in-File Educators (MORE). They’re actually teachers, not an astroturf group (i.e. E4E) You can check them out here http://morecaucusnyc.org/


  3. Peter:

    We agree on E4E. They are a “fifth column” and their members are probably less than a hundred. Many of the E4E leaders spent less than 5 years in the classroom and many never received tenure!

    They will always be a fringe group that will never run candidates for fear of having their reformer friends find out how ineffective they are with teachers.


  4. Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if
    you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that
    automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.

    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time
    and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something
    like this. Please let me know if you run into anything.
    I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward
    to your new updates.


  5. After looking over a handful of the blog posts on your web page, I truly like your way of writing a blog.
    I saved it to my bookmark site list and will be checking back soon.
    Please check out my website too and let me know your opinion.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s